When your refrigerator’s ice maker slows down, jams, or stops producing cubes entirely, the daily annoyance of filling trays or buying bags of ice becomes a real hassle. The root cause is often a tired assembly that has been cycling for years, and the most practical solution is a direct replacement that restores your appliance to its original ice-making rhythm.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind AirfryerBite. Over the past three years, I have analyzed thousands of appliance part specs, cross-referenced compatibility databases, and tracked customer feedback on replacement ice maker assemblies to separate the true OEM-quality fits from the aftermarket duds.
Finding the right refrigerator ice maker means matching your specific model number and understanding whether you need a full assembly kit or just the module, so you avoid a second failure down the line.
How To Choose The Best Refrigerator Ice Maker
Selecting the correct replacement ice maker for your refrigerator goes far beyond picking a cheap option. The wrong part will either not fit mechanically or will have a different wiring harness pin-out, leading to a dead unit in your freezer. You need to base your decision on model compatibility, build material, and the specific type of ice maker your fridge uses.
Model Number Verification Is Non-Negotiable
The most common mistake buyers make is assuming all ice makers are universal. They are not. A Frigidaire assembly designed for a top-mount freezer will not physically align with the mounting holes of a Samsung counter-depth French door model. You must locate your refrigerator’s model number sticker — usually inside the fresh food compartment on the left wall or on the freezer door frame — and cross-reference it against the manufacturer’s approved part list. Every product in this guide includes a specific compatibility roster; if your model is not listed, do not buy it.
OEM vs. Aftermarket Build Quality
Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts are built to the exact specifications of your fridge brand, meaning the plastic mold, the ejection mechanism, and the thermal sensor are identical to what shipped from the factory. Aftermarket ice makers may save you money upfront, but reviewers frequently report thinner plastic that warps, a sensor arm that fails to trigger the fill cycle, or a harness that requires you to splice wires. For a critical component that cycles hundreds of times per year, paying a premium for an OEM-grade assembly typically extends the service life by several years.
Ice Production Rate and Storage Capacity
Most residential refrigerator ice makers produce between 2 and 8 pounds of ice per day. A standard unit with a 115-volt solenoid and a single ejection arm can fill a typical 2-pound bin every 90 to 120 minutes. If your household goes through ice quickly — think parties, daily iced beverages, or a large family — look for an ice maker with a higher wattage motor (around 115 to 250 watts) and a sensor arm that signals the freezer to refill the tray at the correct time. Low-amperage units often freeze the water too slowly, causing the cubes to stick together before the ejection cycle.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LG AEQ73130004 | Premium OEM | LG/Kenmore Elite precision fit | 250 watt motor, stainless steel | Amazon |
| Supplying Demand DA97-13718C | Mid-Range | Samsung counter-depth refrigerators | 6-cube solid tray, electronic eye | Amazon |
| Supplying Demand W11546935 | Mid-Range | Whirlpool model-specific swap | 0.08 Amp, 57.5 watt draw | Amazon |
| Supplying Demand D7824706Q | Mid-Range | Amana/Maytag/Whirlpool compatibility | 4200 ml bin capacity | Amazon |
| Frigidaire IM117000 | Entry Plus | Retrofit top-mount Frigidaire fridges | Sensor arm, top-mount design | Amazon |
| Frigidaire 241798231 | Entry Plus | Frigidaire easy DIY replacement | 115 watt, 8 cu. cm. capacity | Amazon |
| LG AEQ7290 | Entry Level | Budget LG/LFX/LFCS series swap | 8 lb/day production, plastic tray | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. LG AEQ73130004 Genuine OEM Ice Maker Assembly
The LG AEQ73130004 is a genuine OEM assembly that ships directly with LG’s factory specifications — a 250-watt motor and a stainless steel ice tray that resists the corrosion and warping common in all-plastic designs. Reviewers consistently note that it is a 98 percent match for the original part on Kenmore Elite models manufactured by LG, requiring only a 10-minute installation with two screws and a plug connection. The set includes the electronic eye sensor that communicates with the freezer’s main board to stop ice production when the bin is full, eliminating overflow issues.
Customer reports indicate this unit produces a full bin in under 12 hours when using the Ultra Ice mode, which holds the refrigeration cycle longer to accelerate freezing. The wiring harness is pre-terminated with the correct male connector for LG’s proprietary pin layout, so no splicing or crimping is needed. Users who broke the plastic water guide during removal were able to order that separate part, but the ice maker itself remains structurally solid after years of daily cycling.
This is the right choice if you own a mid-range to premium LG refrigerator or a Kenmore Elite with an LG base and want to avoid the hassle of aftermarket guesswork. The upfront cost is higher than budget units, but the stainless tray and OEM validation make it the most dependable long-term investment in this lineup.
Why it’s great
- Genuine LG OEM part with stainless steel tray for corrosion resistance
- Includes pre-terminated connector for exact LG wiring layout
- Ultra Ice mode speeds up production significantly
Good to know
- Plastic water guide is fragile and may break during removal if not careful
- Requires checking specific model compatibility — not universal
2. Supplying Demand DA97-13718C Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly
Designed specifically for Samsung counter-depth French door refrigerators, the DA97-13718C replacement uses a six-cube solid tray with an electronic eye sensor rather than the traditional mechanical arm to detect ice level. This matters because Samsung’s in-door ice maker compartments are prone to ice bridging if the sensor misreads, and an aftermarket sensor that does not align perfectly can cause constant run or no-run cycles. Reviewers report that this unit fits RF22 and RF23 series models with near-OEM precision, though the wiring harness lacks the clip of the original — it still seats tightly enough to maintain electrical contact.
Build quality is mostly plastic, including the tray mechanism, which is a departure from the older metal-bottom OEM design. Some users noted the need to de-ice the compartment every two weeks to prevent the sensor arm from freezing stuck, a common maintenance step for any Samsung ice maker. The solid tray produces standard crescent cubes without the hollow center that some aftermarket molds create, and the unit starts dropping cubes within 24 hours of installation.
If your Samsung refrigerator’s original ice maker failed within three to five years, this replacement offers identical functionality at a lower price than buying direct from Samsung. Keep a small screwdriver handy for the two mounting screws, and protect the thin plastic tabs during shipping handling.
Why it’s great
- Exact fit for popular Samsung RF22/RF23 counter-depth models
- Electronic eye sensor stops overfilling automatically
- Solid tray produces consistent crescent cubes
Good to know
- All-plastic build; less durable than older metal-bottom OEM
- Requires periodic de-icing of the compartment to prevent sensor freeze
3. Supplying Demand W11546935 Refrigerator Ice Maker
This unit is built for contemporary Whirlpool refrigerators, with a low power draw of just 57.5 watts and 0.08 amps that puts minimal stress on the freezer’s wiring circuit. The kit includes the ice maker module itself but retains the original wiring harness, which means you must verify that your existing connector matches the modular plug on this unit. Customers on the W11546935 confirm it is a direct drop-in replacement for models like the Whirlpool W11700250, with a 15-minute installation time involving two loosened screws and one bolt removal.
Reviewers consistently praise the plug-and-play nature of this ice maker — no wire stripping, no soldering, and no adapter harness required. The plastic construction is adequate for normal household use, though one common critique is that the mounting tabs could be thicker to prevent cracking if over-torqued during installation. A few buyers received units with damaged tabs due to inadequate packaging in the original shipment, so inspect the corners immediately upon arrival. Once seated, the unit has been running reliably for months in numerous customer reports, restoring ice production to original levels within a day.
Choose this part if you own a Whirlpool refrigerator manufactured after 2018 and want the lowest power consumption available in a replacement ice maker. The minimal amperage means it produces ice at a moderate pace — roughly one bin every two hours — but that is consistent with Whirlpool’s standard cycle specification.
Why it’s great
- Ultra-low power draw (57.5 watts) reduces freezer electrical load
- True plug-and-play with no wire splicing needed
- Matches OEM fit for modern Whirlpool refrigerators
Good to know
- Mounting tabs can crack if screws are over-tightened
- Packaging may be insufficient; inspect for damage on arrival
4. Supplying Demand D7824706Q Refrigerator Ice Maker
This ice maker replacement casts a wide net of compatibility, fitting Amana, Maytag, KitchenAid, and Whirlpool models alongside dozens of alternate part numbers. It operates on a standard 115-volt circuit and includes a 4,200-milliliter storage bin that holds roughly 8.9 pints of ice, enough for a medium household’s daily use. One of the strongest points in customer feedback is the price-to-function ratio — buyers report that it solved the exact same failure pattern (cube jam, no ejection, or water overflow) at a fraction of what the manufacturer wanted for the branded part.
The installation does require you to reuse your original wiring harness, because the SDD7813010 harness is not included. This is a minor inconvenience that adds five minutes to the job, but it also means you need to verify your pin connector matches the new unit’s plug. Early reviewers on Maytag bottom-freezer models noted the challenge of reaching the front screw inside a tight freezer drawer, though most managed with a standard ¼-inch nut driver. The plastic construction feels comparable to the OEM part, and the unit has been running continuously in several reported cases.
If you own an older Whirlpool-platform refrigerator and want to avoid paying the OEM premium, this is the most versatile budget-friendly option. Just be certain your model number appears in the compatibility list — the plug shape changes across model years.
Why it’s great
- Covers a wide range of Amana/Maytag/Whirlpool models
- Large 4.2-liter storage bin capacity
- Significantly cheaper than OEM branded equivalents
Good to know
- Wiring harness not included; must reuse original
- Front screw access in bottom-freezer drawers is cramped
5. Frigidaire IM117000 Ice Maker Kit
The Frigidaire IM117000 is a complete ice maker kit designed for top-mount refrigerators, meaning it includes the ice bin, mounting hardware, and a mechanical sensor arm that stops production when the container is full. It is intended for pre-wired refrigerators that already have the internal water solenoid connection — if your fridge does not have the wiring, the solenoid wires in this kit may be at their limit to reach the terminal block. Installers report a 15-minute process with a screwdriver, fastening the module to the freezer ceiling or back wall depending on the model.
Customer feedback is split between good initial performance and concerns about long-term build quality. Early production runs produced ice quickly after a short break-in period, but several reviewers experienced a slowdown after three to six months, with the sensor arm failing to drop and forcing manual intervention. The unit is all-plastic, whereas the original Frigidaire part on some models featured a metal tray that lasted over a decade. Buyers expecting that same longevity should be cautious — this newer plastic iteration trades durability for lower cost of manufacturing.
This kit makes sense if you are retrofitting a Frigidaire top-mount that never had an ice maker, or if you need a complete drop-in assembly with a bin included. For refrigerators that originally shipped with a metal-tray unit, consider searching for a NOS (new old stock) OEM part instead.
Why it’s great
- Complete kit with ice bin and all installation accessories
- Mechanical sensor arm prevents bin overflow
- Fast 15-minute installation for pre-wired fridges
Good to know
- All-plastic tray is less durable than older metal versions
- Some units slow production after 3-6 months due to arm failure
6. Frigidaire 241798231 Ice Maker Assembly Kit
This Frigidaire assembly is engineered to the exact OEM specifications of the 241798231 part number, which makes it a reliable option for owners of Frigidaire top-freezer and side-by-side refrigerators. The unit draws 115 watts and measures 11.75 inches deep, 4.62 inches wide, and 4.12 inches tall — a compact footprint that fits into tight freezer compartments. The plug connector is identical to the factory unit, and users report that the new cables are actually slightly longer than the original, making it easier to route the wires away from moving components during the swap.
One of the standout details in customer reviews is the production ramp-up: the ice maker takes about three days to reach maximum output, which is actually a normal feature of the thermal stabilization cycle. Once settled, it produces ice at a rate that matches or exceeds the original, with one user describing it as “drops ice like crazy” after the break-in period. The only tool required is a ¼-inch nut driver for the two mounting screws, and the entire process takes less than five minutes for an experienced DIYer.
If you want a Frigidaire-branded replacement without paying an inflated service fee, this kit delivers genuine engineering at an entry-level price point. Just make sure your specific freezer model is listed in the compatibility guide before ordering.
Why it’s great
- Genuine Frigidaire engineering for accurate fit and cycle timing
- Slightly longer cables simplify wire routing behind the assembly
- Five-minute installation with a single nut driver
Good to know
- Takes up to three days to reach maximum ice production rate
- Must verify compatibility with your specific model number
7. LG AEQ7290 Refrigerator Ice Maker
The LG AEQ7290 is the most affordable entry in this roundup, offering compatibility with dozens of LG LFC, LFX, and LFCS series refrigerators. It produces up to 8 pounds of ice per day with a plastic ice tray that mirrors the original LG design. The fitment is a direct match for models like the LFX25973ST and LFCS27596S, and multiple verified customers confirm that the mounting holes align perfectly without drilling or modification. The connector plug matches the LG pin-out, so no wire cutting is necessary.
The biggest trade-off with this budget-tier unit is longevity in hard-water environments. Several reviews note that while the motor rarely fails, mineral scale from unfiltered water builds up in the plastic tray over 18 to 24 months, causing the ejection arm to stick and the tray to overflow. Since the tray is not replaceable independently, you must swap the whole assembly when that happens. Users who installed a water filter inline reported significantly longer service intervals. The 30-day warranty is short, so testing the unit thoroughly immediately after installation is critical.
The AEQ7290 is a sensible, low-investment fix if your original LG unit died suddenly and you need a quick replacement that works right out of the box. Pair it with an inline water filter to extend the tray life beyond the typical two-year mark.
Why it’s great
- Exact fit for dozens of LG LFC/LFX/LFCS models
- Produces 8 pounds of ice per day — standard for most households
- Plug-and-play installation with no wire splicing
Good to know
- Plastic tray prone to scale buildup with hard water; filter recommended
- Only 30-day warranty; test immediately after installation
FAQ
How do I know if my ice maker failure is mechanical or electrical?
Can I install an aftermarket ice maker if the shape looks close to my OEM part?
Why does my new ice maker take a few days to start producing ice at full volume?
Is it worth paying more for a stainless steel ice maker tray over a plastic one?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the refrigerator ice maker winner is the LG AEQ73130004 because the stainless steel tray and 250-watt motor provide the best combination of durability and rapid cycle times, backed by genuine OEM validation. If you need a reliable fit for a Samsung counter-depth fridge, grab the Supplying Demand DA97-13718C. And for a low-cost fix on Whirlpool-platform refrigerators, nothing beats the value of the Supplying Demand W11546935.