A great pie is more than just dessert — it is the centerpiece of a holiday table, a taste of home for a faraway friend, and a tangible expression of care that a store-bought box simply cannot match. The challenge lies in finding a mail-order pie that survives the shipping ordeal and arrives tasting as fresh as the baker intended, with a crust that is flaky, a filling that is generous, and a flavor that justifies the wait.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind AirfryerBite. After analyzing hundreds of customer reviews, examining packaging methods, and comparing the specs of pies from the country’s most respected bakeries, I have a clear picture of which mail-order pies truly deliver.
This guide cuts through the marketing to help you select the best option for your occasion, focusing on the flavors, crust quality, and shipping reliability that define the best mail order pies available today.
How To Choose The Best Mail Order Pies
Ordering a pie online introduces variables that a local bakery purchase simply does not — shipping time, packaging quality, and the potential for damage are all real concerns. Knowing what to look for before you buy ensures you end up with a dessert that tastes as good as it looks.
Baking Method: Fully Baked vs. Ready-to-Bake
This is the first major fork in the road. Fully baked pies, like the Derby-Pie, arrive ready to thaw and serve — perfect for immediate gratification or gifting. Ready-to-bake pies, often sent frozen with dry ice, develop a superior fresh-from-the-oven crust and hot filling. Consider your timeline and oven access when choosing between the two.
Pie Size and Serving Count
Pies in this category range from 6-inch personal tarts to 10-inch deep-dish family desserts. A 9-inch pie typically yields 7 slices, while a 10-inch pie can serve 8 to 10. For a table of six or more, a 2-pack of 9-inch pies or a single 10-inch pie is the practical minimum.
Shipping and Packaging Integrity
The single biggest risk with mail-order pies is damage during transit. Look for pies packed in heavy cardboard bakery boxes, insulated coolers, or with dry ice. Products from AmishTastes and Burgers’ Smokehouse receive particular praise for their robust packaging. Customer reviews are the best indicator — consistently positive feedback on arrival condition is worth more than any marketing promise.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kern’s Kitchen Derby-Pie | Premium | Authentic Kentucky Tradition | 9-inch, Fully Baked, Chocolate Walnut | Amazon |
| Aunt Eula’s Pecan Pie | Premium | Texas-Style Pecan Pie | 9-inch Deep Dish, Pre-Cooked | Amazon |
| David’s Cookies Grandé Apple & Cherry Combo | Mid-Range | Classic Fruit Pie Variety | Two 10-inch, Ready-to-Bake | Amazon |
| David’s Cookies Southern Pecan Pie 2-Pack | Mid-Range | Gourmet Pecan Gifting | Two 10-inch, Buttery Golden Crust | Amazon |
| David’s Cookies Grandé Peach Pie 2-Pack | Mid-Range | Summer Peach Flavor | Two 10-inch, Freestone Peaches | Amazon |
| AmishTastes Bird-in-Hand Shoofly Pie | Budget | Authentic Amish Wet-Bottom Pie | Two 9-inch, 28 Oz Each | Amazon |
| Burgers’ Smokehouse Strawberry Rhubarb Pie | Premium | Small-Batch Fruit Pie | Fresh, Frozen, Dry Ice Packaging | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Kern’s Kitchen Derby-Pie® – Original Chocolate Nut Dessert (2 Pack)
Kern’s Kitchen Derby-Pie is the original chocolate walnut pie, a Kentucky tradition since 1954 and the official pie of the Kentucky Derby Festival. This 9-inch, 20-ounce pie serves 8 and arrives fully baked and shipped frozen, meaning you only need to thaw and warm it in the oven for that fresh-baked experience. The buttery, flaky crust is pressed by hand using a technique passed down through four generations.
The filling is a balanced blend of rich chocolate and hand-sorted California walnuts that is not overly sweet, making it a sophisticated alternative to pecan pie. Customer reviews consistently highlight its authentic taste and excellent value, with one reviewer noting it “felt like being back in Kentucky.” The 2-pack provides two pies, making it ideal for holiday gatherings or shipping one to a friend.
Shipping reliability is excellent thanks to protective insulation and frozen transport. While it is a premium option, the combination of heritage, handcrafted quality, and crowd-pleasing flavor earns it the top spot. The only minor consideration is that the chocolate-walnut filling may not appeal to those seeking a classic fruit pie.
Why it’s great
- Authentic Kentucky recipe since 1954 with handcrafted crust
- Fully baked and shipped frozen for easy thaw-and-serve convenience
- Balanced chocolate walnut filling is not overly sweet
Good to know
- Specialized flavor may not suit those wanting classic fruit pies
- Premium pricing reflects handcrafted quality and shipping method
2. Aunt Eula’s Grand Champion Pecan Pie
Aunt Eula’s Grand Champion Pecan Pie is a Texas tradition baked with the finest fresh shelled pecans available. This 9-inch deep dish pie is pre-cooked and weighs 2.5 pounds, offering a generous portion of filling compared to standard pies. The old family recipe produces a filling that reviewers describe as “not too sweet” with “lots of pecans,” striking the ideal balance between rich custard and nutty crunch.
Customer reviews are overwhelmingly positive, with many emphasizing its buttery crust and nostalgic homemade quality. One verified buyer called it “heaven in your mouth,” while a Texas ex-pat noted it provided a “taste of home.” The pie ships quickly and arrives in excellent condition, making it a reliable choice for Thanksgiving or a special gift.
The only consistent drawback mentioned is the premium price point, which some feel is high for what it is. However, the unanimous praise for its flavor and texture suggests the quality justifies the investment for pecan pie enthusiasts. If you are looking for a pecan pie that tastes like it came from a Southern grandmother’s kitchen, this is the one.
Why it’s great
- Generous 2.5-pound deep dish pie with abundant pecans
- Not overly sweet, with a buttery crust and rich filling
- Fast, reliable shipping praised in customer reviews
Good to know
- Premium price point may not suit budget buyers
- Pre-cooked, so you cannot bake it fresh yourself
3. David’s Cookies Grandé Apple and Cherry Pie Combo
David’s Cookies Grandé Apple and Cherry Pie Combo includes one 10-inch apple pie and one 10-inch cherry pie, offering a classic fruit pie variety pack that is ideal for gatherings. These ready-to-bake pies feature golden flaky crusts that develop a homemade texture when baked in your own oven. The apple pie uses cinnamon-spiced apples, while the cherry pie is filled with tart cherries, providing two distinct flavor profiles from a single order.
Customer reviews indicate solid satisfaction, with one reviewer calling the cherry pie the “best ever” and praising its pastry and cherries. The pies arrive shipped together, and the 2-pack format makes them practical for large events or for keeping one while gifting the other. The freeze-and-thaw convenience allows you to bake them at your own pace.
A few reviewers noted the pies can be a bit sweet, so if you prefer a more tart balance, this may be worth considering. Overall, this combo delivers reliable quality and generous portions for the price, making it a strong mid-range choice for anyone who wants both apple and cherry on the table.
Why it’s great
- Two 10-inch pies for excellent value and variety
- Ready-to-bake format delivers a fresh-from-the-oven result
- Classic apple and cherry flavors please a crowd
Good to know
- Some find the cherry pie a bit too sweet
- Requires oven baking, not ready to serve immediately
4. David’s Cookies Baked Southern Pecan Pie 10″ 2-Pack
David’s Cookies Baked Southern Pecan Pie 2-Pack delivers two 10-inch pies filled with roasted pecans and a rich brown sugar filling. Each pie features a buttery, golden crust that complements the nutty, caramelized flavor of the pecan filling. These are fully baked and ready to serve, making them an ideal choice for last-minute entertaining or gifting.
Customer feedback emphasizes the high quality of the crust and filling, with several reviewers calling the pies “excellent” and noting they were well-received at events. The 2-pack format is practical for larger gatherings or for shipping one to a loved one. The pies are also OU Kosher Dairy certified, adding dietary flexibility.
As with the David’s Cookies fruit pies, some reviewers found the sweetness level a bit high for their taste. The packaging is generally good, but ensuring the box is not crushed during shipping is always a consideration. For a straightforward, high-quality pecan pie that arrives ready to eat, this is a dependable option.
Why it’s great
- Two 10-inch pies fully baked and ready to serve immediately
- Buttery golden crust with roasted pecan and brown sugar filling
- OU Kosher Dairy certified for dietary compliance
Good to know
- Sweetness level may be high for some palates
- Packaging can occasionally be damaged during shipping
5. David’s Cookies Ready To Bake Grandé Peach Pie 10″ 2-Pack
David’s Cookies Grandé Peach Pie 2-Pack brings two 10-inch pies packed with sweet, juicy freestone peaches to your table. These are ready-to-bake pies, meaning you pop them in the oven to develop a golden crust and warm, bubbling filling. This format is ideal for creating that fresh-baked impression with minimal effort, and the peaches provide a bright, summery flavor that works year-round.
Reviews are positive, with customers describing the pies as “very good” and appreciating the convenience. The freestone peaches ensure a consistent texture and flavor throughout the filling. The 2-pack is excellent for gifting or for one pie to be enjoyed now and the other frozen for later.
The primary consideration is the same across David’s Cookies pies: sweetness levels can be high for some individuals. Additionally, as a ready-to-bake pie, you need oven access and about 45 minutes of baking time. If you love peach pie and want a reliable, gourmet version shipped to your door, this 2-pack delivers on all fronts.
Why it’s great
- Two 10-inch peach pies with premium freestone peach filling
- Ready-to-bake format for fresh-from-oven results
- Perfect for gifting or freezing one for later
Good to know
- Requires oven baking time before serving
- Sweetness level may be too high for some
6. AmishTastes Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie (Pack of 2)
The AmishTastes Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie offers a taste of Pennsylvania’s Amish country, made with a traditional “gooey” molasses filling and a crumb top. Each 9-inch pie weighs 28 ounces and provides around 7 servings. The pies are packed in a white bakery-style box of heavy cardboard designed to help ensure safe shipping, and they can be frozen for long storage.
Customer opinions are sharply divided. Many loyal fans love the “fresh, delicious, unique” flavor and authentic Amish recipe, calling it a “shoofly pie to die for.” However, a significant number of reviews report issues with the pie arriving damaged, with the filling sloshed inside the box. Some found the pies bland, runny, and lacking molasses flavor, describing them as an “insult to shoofly pies.”
The mixed feedback on both quality and packaging consistency makes this a gamble. It is a budget-friendly option that can be a wonderful nostalgic treat if it arrives intact, but the risk of damage and variable quality is higher than with the premium options. If you are determined to try an authentic wet-bottom shoofly pie, this is the entry point, but be aware of the potential pitfalls.
Why it’s great
- Authentic Amish wet-bottom shoofly pie with molasses flavor
- Two 9-inch pies in a pack for a reasonable entry price
- Can be frozen for extended storage
Good to know
- Packaging can lead to the pie filling spilling during shipping
- Inconsistent quality reported by some customers
7. Burgers’ Smokehouse Fresh Country Pies (Strawberry Rhubarb)
Burgers’ Smokehouse Strawberry Rhubarb Pie is a small-batch, frozen pie shipped in a super sturdy cooler with dry ice to guarantee its arrival in perfect condition. This is a fresh, from-freezer-to-oven pie that uses top-quality ingredients, including fresh ripened fruit. The packaging is widely praised in customer reviews, with one buyer noting the pie arrived “packaged great in dry ice” and ready to bake.
Customer sentiment is uniformly positive, with reviewers calling it a “must have pie” and praising its delicious flavor. The strawberry rhubarb combination is a classic that many find hard to source locally, making this a great choice for those craving a specific fruit pie. The small-batch recipe aims for homemade goodness without the work.
The main downside is the premium price, which several reviewers acknowledged as “a bit pricey.” Additionally, only one pie is included in the order, so if you are feeding a large group, you may need to order multiples. For a specialized fruit pie with exceptional shipping care, Burgers’ Smokehouse is a top contender.
Why it’s great
- Exceptional dry ice packaging ensures perfect arrival
- Delicious small-batch strawberry rhubarb flavor
- Fresh-frozen quality with easy oven preparation
Good to know
- Premium price for a single pie
- Only one pie per order, not a multi-pack
FAQ
How are mail-order pies shipped to stay fresh?
Can I reheat a mail-order pie that arrives fully baked?
What is the difference between a wet-bottom and dry-bottom shoofly pie?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the mail order pies winner is the Kern’s Kitchen Derby-Pie because it combines heritage, handcrafted quality, and a unique chocolate-walnut flavor that stands out from typical pies. If you want an authentic Southern pecan pie with a buttery crust, grab the Aunt Eula’s Grand Champion Pecan Pie. And for a classic fruit pie variety that serves a crowd, nothing beats the David’s Cookies Grandé Apple and Cherry Pie Combo.