For years, the canned tuna aisle has been dominated by water-packed, dry, flaky chunks that require a heavy dose of mayo to be palatable. Switching to tuna preserved in premium olive oil unlocks a whole new world of texture and flavor — tender, silky slices that shine straight from the jar or on top of a crisp salad.
I’m Mohammad Maruf — the founder and writer behind AirfryerBite. I’ve spent countless hours poring over nutritional facts, sourcing methods, and packaging standards for premium tinned seafood to separate the truly superior jars from the overcrowded shelf of mediocre options.
This guide breaks down five standout choices based on flavor, texture, and sourcing ethics so you can confidently select the best tuna in olive oil for your pantry without second-guessing your purchase.
How To Choose The Best Tuna In Olive Oil
Not all jars or tins labeled “tuna in olive oil” deliver the same experience. The species of tuna, the quality of the oil, and the fishing method each play a distinct role in the final taste, texture, and nutritional profile of the product.
Identify the Tuna Species
Bonito del norte (white albacore from northern Spain) offers a mild, delicate flavor and firm yet tender slices. Skipjack, on the other hand, has a stronger, more pronounced fish taste and a flakier texture. Standard albacore sits somewhere in between. Your choice here defines the entire eating experience.
Inspect the Packing Oil
Look for “extra virgin olive oil” (EVOO) if you want the richest, fruitiest flavor profile. “Pure olive oil” is a blend of refined and virgin oils and delivers a cleaner, more neutral taste. Avoid cans that list “olive oil” without further detail — they may contain low-grade refined oil that adds little to the tuna.
Verify the Sourcing and Fishing Method
Pole-and-line or troll-caught tuna is generally smaller, younger, and lower in mercury compared to large, older fish caught by industrial longlines. Brands that specify their fishing method and origin — like the Cantabrian Sea or the Pacific — typically invest more in quality and sustainability.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ortiz White Tuna (7.76oz Jar) | Premium Jar | Gourmet single-use, salads, snacking | 7.76oz net / 5.29oz drained; pole & line | Amazon |
| Ortiz White Tuna (3.95oz Can, 12-Pack) | Premium Multi-Pack | Staples, lunches, affordable gourmet | 2.89oz drained per can; EVOO packing | Amazon |
| Callipo Italian Tuna (2.8oz, 9-Pack) | Mid-Range | Lunchboxes, quick snacks, variety | 2.8oz per can; Italian origin | Amazon |
| Wild Planet Skipjack Solid Light (2.82oz, 12-Pack) | Value Bundle | Budget-friendly, low mercury, high protein | 13g protein; pure olive oil | Amazon |
| Wild Planet Albacore EVOO (5oz, 12-Pack) | Premium Steak Cuts | High-protein meals, recipe substitution | 5oz cans; 26g protein per serving | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Ortiz White Tuna in Olive Oil (7.76oz Glass Jar)
This glass jar from Ortiz is the gold standard for anyone transitioning from bland water-packed tuna. The bonito del norte — white albacore caught seasonally off the Cantabrian Sea — offers firm, meaty slices that hold their shape beautifully. The olive oil packing medium is fragrant and high-quality, eliminating any need for mayo or additional dressing.
At 7.76 ounces net weight with a drained weight of 5.29 ounces, this single jar is designed for immediate consumption or a single generous salad. The jars allow you to see the quality of the tuna before opening, and the glass packaging avoids any metallic aftertaste that can sometimes transfer from tin cans.
Traditional pole-and-line fishing and hand-cleaning processes, practiced by the same family-run company for over 130 years, result in a product with exceptionally low mercury risk and superb texture. This is the jar you reach for when you want to impress without cooking.
Why it’s great
- Firm, non-flaky slices retain their integrity on salads and plates
- Premium Spanish olive oil packing enhances, not masks, the tuna flavor
- Glass jar eliminates metallic taste and lets you inspect contents
Good to know
- Single jar format — not ideal for stocking up in bulk
- Premium pricing compared to standard canned tuna multipacks
2. Ortiz White Tuna in Olive Oil (3.95oz Can, 12-Pack)
This 12-pack of 3.95-ounce tins delivers the same exceptional Ortiz quality as the glass jar but in a more practical, pantry-friendly format. Each can contains 2.89 ounces of drained bonito del norte, making them ideal for single-person lunches, work bag snacks, or quick pasta dishes.
The smaller can size means you open exactly what you need without waste, and the multi-pack brings the per-unit cost down considerably without sacrificing the mild, buttery texture that Ortiz is famous for. The tuna is hand-packed with quality Spanish olive oil, so every tin opens to reveal clean, intact slices rather than mushy shreds.
Sourced from the Cantabrian Sea and caught during the natural season, this albacore delivers 14.1 grams of protein per can. The traditional handling ensures the fish retains its moisture and structural integrity, making it a reliable staple for both Mediterranean-style meals and simple cracker-topped appetizers.
Why it’s great
- 12-pack offers the best per-can value for Ortiz premium tuna
- Individual cans stay fresh longer than a single open jar
- Consistently tender, non-fishy slices across every tin
Good to know
- Smaller drained weight (2.89oz) per can means you may need two for a full meal
- Tin cans can sometimes develop a slight metallic note if stored too long
3. Callipo Italian Canned Tuna in Olive Oil (2.8oz, 9-Pack)
Callipo brings a distinctly Italian approach to tinned tuna, offering a 9-pack of 2.8-ounce cans packed in olive oil. The tuna has a clean, mild flavor profile that pairs well with citrus, fresh herbs, and crusty bread, making it a versatile option for antipasti boards or light lunches.
The smaller can size — 2.8 ounces — is geared toward snacking or single-use recipes. Each can opens to reveal finely textured, moist tuna that breaks apart easily, which is a different experience from the firm, meaty slices of Ortiz. This texture works better when you plan to flake the tuna into salads, pasta, or spreads.
While specific fishing and sourcing details are less prominently communicated than with Ortiz or Wild Planet, Callipo has a long heritage in Italian conservas. The olive oil packing is clean and well-balanced, offering a respectable entry point into the world of imported olive oil tuna without the top-tier price of Spanish brands.
Why it’s great
- Convenient 9-pack for frequent lunch or snack use
- Mild Italian flavor works well with Mediterranean ingredients
- Smaller tins reduce waste if you only need a portion
Good to know
- Texture is softer and flakier — not ideal for those who prefer firm slices
- Fishing method and oil type are not as clearly specified as competitors
4. Wild Planet Albacore Wild Tuna in Extra Virgin Olive Oil (5oz, 12-Pack)
Wild Planet markets this product as “tuna steak” — and the description fits. Each 5-ounce can contains hand-cut, hand-packed albacore pieces packed in organic extra virgin olive oil, delivering 26 grams of clean protein and 781 mg of DHA and EPA omega-3s per serving. This is a serious nutritional powerhouse with a rich, steak-like bite.
The key differentiator here is the use of extra virgin olive oil rather than refined or pure olive oil. You get a noticeably fruitier, more robust oil flavor that coats the tuna and adds depth to every forkful. The albacore is firm and flaky rather than soft, making it a strong candidate for hearty salads, grain bowls, or even light searing.
Wild Planet uses 100% pole-and-line fishing, which targets smaller, younger tuna naturally lower in mercury.
Why it’s great
- Highest protein count (26g) among the products reviewed here
- Extra virgin olive oil adds bright, grassy flavor notes
- Large 5oz can is satisfying as a main dish base
Good to know
- EVOO flavor may overpower delicate recipes that need neutral oil
- Albacore texture is firmer and more dense than skipjack or bonito
5. Wild Planet Skipjack Solid Light Tuna in Pure Olive Oil (2.82oz, 12-Pack)
This 12-pack of 2.82-ounce cans from Wild Planet offers an approachable entry point into the olive-oil-packed tuna category. The skipjack is light in color and flavor, with a noticeably stronger fish taste than bonito del norte or albacore. It works well for those who enjoy a more pronounced tuna identity in their dishes.
Packed in pure olive oil with only added sea salt, these single-serve tins contain 13 grams of protein each and are non-GMO verified. Skipjack is naturally one of the lowest-mercury tuna species, which makes this a practical choice for frequent consumption, especially for meal-preppers or families watching mercury intake.
The texture is soft and flaky rather than firm, which makes it ideal for mixing into tuna salads, casseroles, or spreads. Each can is exactly one serving, so there is no leftover storage. However, those accustomed to the rich, buttery texture of Ortiz may find the skipjack experience noticeably leaner and more rustic.
Why it’s great
- Skipjack is among the lowest-mercury tuna choices available
- Budget-friendly multipack for everyday use
- Simple, clean ingredients with no fillers or water
Good to know
- Stronger fishy flavor compared to white albacore or bonito del norte
- Small 2.82oz can is best suited as a snack or light lunch component
FAQ
Do I need to drain the olive oil before eating the tuna?
Why does Ortiz tuna cost significantly more than standard canned tuna?
Which tuna in olive oil has the lowest mercury content?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the best tuna in olive oil winner is the Ortiz White Tuna (7.76oz Glass Jar) because it delivers unmatched texture, flavor, and visual appeal in a single serving. If you want the same premium quality in a more practical, pantry-stocking format, grab the Ortiz 12-Pack (3.95oz Cans). And for a budget-friendly, low-mercury option perfect for daily lunches, nothing beats the Wild Planet Skipjack 12-Pack.